Dallas ISD Has 35 Schools Rated Worst in the State

FacebookTwitterLinkedInGoogle+Email

Dallas ISD Flunks 201235 Dallas ISD schools have made the annual list of the worst public schools in Texas.  The PEG (Public Education Grant) List was released by the TEA and triggers a State law that allows students from those schools to transfer to any other school in the district they desire.

Dallas had the largest number of unacceptable schools in the entire State at 8% – double the number of Houston schools.

Some campuses avoided the list this year because the state issued no performance ratings in 2012 as the state transitions from the old TAKS test to the new STAAR testing program taking effect in 2013.

The number of failing schools was less this year than last but were still higher than previous years because when the state artificially inflated the performance ratings of many schools using the Texas Projection Measure (TPM) which allowed students with failing grades to be counted as passing based on a “prediction” that they may pass sometime in the future.

Dallas ISD 2013-2014 PEG List

2012 campuses with 50% or less of the students passing TAKS/STAAR* in any two of the preceding three years: 2010 2011 and 2012 or the school was rated Academically Unacceptable in 2010 or 2011. No state accountability ratings were issued in 2012.
   *Based on TAKS reading/English language arts writing mathematics social studies or science in 2010 and 2011 and STAAR (at the TAKS-equivalency standard) for grades 3-8 and TAKS at grades 10 and 11 in reading/ELA or mathematics only in 2012.

A MACEO SMITH NEW TECH H S

ANNIE WEBB BLANTON EL

BOUDE STOREY MIDDLE

BRYAN ADAMS H S

DAVID W CARTER H S

E B COMSTOCK MIDDLE

EDWARD H CARY MIDDLE

EDWARD TITCHE EL

EDWIN J KIEST EL

EMMETT J CONRAD H S

FRANCISCO MEDRANO MIDDLE

FRANKLIN D ROOSEVELT H S

FRED F FLORENCE MIDDLE

H GRADY SPRUCE H S

H I HOLLAND EL AT LISBON

HILLCREST H S

J L LONG MIDDLE

J W RAY LEARNING CENTER

JAMES MADISON HIGH SCHOOL

JOHN B HOOD MIDDLE

JOHN W RUNYON EL

JUSTIN F KIMBALL H S

L G PINKSTON HIGH SCHOOL

LEE A MCSHAN JR EL

LINCOLN HUMANITIES/COMMUNICATIONS

NORTH DALLAS H S

OLIVER WENDELL HOLMES HUMANITIES

ROGER Q MILLS EL

S S CONNER EL

SAM TASBY MIDDLE

SEAGOVILLE H S

T W BROWNE MIDDLE

THOMAS L MARSALIS EL

W W SAMUELL H S

WOODROW WILSON H S

 

Tagged with: , , , ,
Posted in Giving Grades
35 comments
21st century education
21st century education

Yeah right, all of these are hood and or Latino schools. Which means that there is little to no parental involvement, language barriers, and the students are really concerned with sports and entertainment rather than education. Parents have to step it up just as much as school staff. How much can we change the school system when people are not doing what it takes to help educate their own children. Most people, not all think, of school today as a free daycare system. Think about it, every break (spring and summer) parents are dying because they cant wait until school starts back so they can get rid of their kids. Just check the comments on Facebook  Every stakeholder in the community has to work together to make education work. My 5 year old son can read, not because the school taught him but because my wife and I started teaching him when he was 3. Maybe we should be more concerned with helping to educated our kids than making sure they have the latest Jordan's or cell phones.

 PBX
PBX

They really have to redo their education system if they want to improve on it.

GoldStar
GoldStar like.author.displayName 1 Like

Exul Lux, you are deserving of our highest accolades. When Sandy Kress decided being a hack politician and two bit attorney were not enough glory and decided to pass himself off as an expert in educational testing, he did immeasurable damage to our educational system.

Added to that is the queen of cheating, Michelle Rhee, and her bogus Stand for the Children that is just a pipeline to feed more posers here in Dallas.

Rhee's actual teaching record has been exposed as well as the massive cheating that was occurring in DC.

Back to you, the humble teacher doing God's work, well, Kress and Rhee don't care about children who don't fit their linear model of learn just enough to bring them glory -- then fail later on down the line because the kids have not been educated. Kress's own kids are in private school with the excuse they one of them likes Greek and must stay at the school to have a class in Greek.

Rhee, Kress, Stand for the Children, Wendy Kopp, Mike Miles are all living large off the backs of poor childen and taxpayers. History will expose them for the sociopaths they are, but it will take a bit longer for us to come out of the Dark Ages of this idea of replacing educators with data technicians. Long term, the data technicians don't give students the skills they need for college or the workforce. It's all short term increase in test scores that are not valid measures of content.

 

In the meantime, forget the list of bad schools. Your school is doing an exemplary job.

exul lux
exul lux like.author.displayName 1 Like

First, I want to point out that a cursory glance at the list makes it appear as though most DISD high schools are on it, including Woodrow. Interpret that as you will. 

 

Secondly, and more importantly, I want to point out that the school at which I teach is represented, and that in this case the data used to condemn us to this status is radically flawed, and does not begin to represent the quality of work that takes place by both teachers and students, not to mention administration.

 

I'll just come out with it- I teach at Emmett Conrad High School. We have a large population of refugees from Burma, Nepal, Bhutan, Africa, Iraq, and other countries. I don't know the exact numbers, especially since many of the kids have huge errors on their files (such as kids being listed as Native American when they are from Nepal, which shares language similarities and geographical proximity to India?? Only possible connection I can imagine, Indian/Indian. Who enters these kids into the system?) In any case, it is significant. These students are forced to take the standardized tests within a very short time once they have arrived in this country. They are supposedly allowed bilingual dictionaries during the tests, but many speak languages for which we have almost no such tools, or for which the tools are inadequate (photocopied attempts obtained through refugee services for the more obscure languages, which is almost all of those we need.) I have attempted to obtain dictionaries and have seen maybe a few slim Arabic-English editions, if that.

 

Our African students are actually classified as African-American, and tested accordingly.

 

Unlike Spanish, the first languages of these students uses totally different characters/alphabet from English. 

I have tried to translate at least my basic vocabulary, using many online resources, and have had kids (usually the Burmese) look shocked and amazed "who wrote this?" The Nepali kids laugh because there's always something wrong with the translations I have found online, but kindly point out that I should just use Hindi, which I have also displayed, because it looks the same even though it is pronounced differently.

 

The refugee kids generally work very hard, and humble me with their transition to American culture and the speed with which they learn a language so foreign to their own. In attending some of their cultural events on campus, I have learned that some don't even know where Central Expressway is located, even though they live and attend school very close to the Park Lane exit. They have come, via charities and the State Department, directly from refugee camps to low income apartment complexes (which are always in threat of being razed to create another "upscale" area of Dallas.)

 

Our school does what we can for these kids, even though district programs for English learners are geared towards those who speak Spanish. The honor rolls are overflowing with their names. 

 

The American-born, or even those kids born in Latin America but raised here, have a wonderful and rare experience to learn, on such a truly international campus. We are all so busy jumping through the official hoops that no one really has time, nor is there the flexibility in any but a few classes, to take enough advantage of this unusual opportunity. So the kids tend to stay with those they know, and homogenize as much as possible.

 

In spite of all the obstacles, Conrad possessed so much that a quality school should exemplify. Sadly, in our case, after being crammed through the regulation bubble-holes of standardized testing, that which emerges on the other side is just the equivalent of too many colors of Play-Doh being pressed through a pasta maker - a grayish mess that looks like failure. In my opinion, the problem is, once again, with the ill-suited assessment instrument.

 

PaulTrevizo
PaulTrevizo

Wasn't the former principal of A Maceo--New Tech promoted by Mike Miles to Executive Director because of the "excellent" work he had done as a principal?  I didn't realize "excellent" work meant getting his school in the academically unacceptable category. 

wrong
wrong

 @PaulTrevizo

 New Tech was opened at the A Maceo Smith building to cover up the fact A Maceo Smith had so many years of failure that it would be closed by TEA. Hinojosa pulled a typical slime move by allowing the failing principal and school to just move to Wilmer Hutchins to break their losing streak. Same principal loser at a different place thanks to SIN.

TEA apparently hasn't figured out the slick move and thinks New Tech is A maceo smith when that school moved to another  building to continue failing with no consequences. Will continue failing with SIN's pick of a principal.

exul lux
exul lux

 @wrong  @PaulTrevizo I substituted at the New Tech A Maceo. There was a completely new structure, students doing almost all work on computers, tiny school population (just 120-some freshmen.) As far as I knew, since the principal was present and seemed quite involved, was that it was pretty experimental, something that had been developed elsewhere and was being tried here. He mentioned that it was challenging to implement, and I believed him. The students complained at the level of rigor, and some were in the process of transferring back to their home schools. I am not defending or condemning, simply sharing what I witnessed. I believe the school had been restructured and re-opened under the policy which allows a chronically-failing school to do so if it implements a completely new approach, with all-new programs.

wilmerized
wilmerized

 @exul lux  @wrong  @PaulTrevizo The faculty, students, and principal of failing A Maceo just went south to the newly opened Wilmer Hutchins campus. They failed again there.

New Tech was a campus opened as subterfuge for the fact that the principal and faculty of Amaceo, which would have been shut, just picked up and moved south. No principal or faculty replacement.

New Tech is a magnet. What did you think happened to the rest of the sports crazed Amaceo, SIN's favorite? They are altogether at a different building unless you think 120 students were all that was left of Amaceo.

Amaceo was NOT restructured and reopened. A magnet opened on the Amaceo campus while failing principal was moved with students to another campus. Get real.

ndno
ndno

Your information is incorrect.  The scores for this year are the same as 2010-2011 because the 2012 test did not count.  Also TPM was not a factor because it was discountinued.  I really like this blog, but mkae sure the info. is factual.  Those schools on the list did not meet the minimum standards in 2011, but while the 2012 scores did improve they did not count...therefore the schools must remain on the list for 2 years.  unfortunate, but true....

disdblogger
disdblogger moderator like.author.displayName 1 Like

TPM was a factor in the 2010-2011 numbers which you correctly state are the basis for this year's numbers.  This same information was reported in several state and local newspapers and we stand by the blog post as accurate.

Ndno
Ndno

@disdblogger

disdblogger
disdblogger moderator

 @Ndno 

Thanks for the input.  We have changed the text to read "when" instead of "because" for clarity.

Ndno
Ndno

@Ndno http://www.tea.state.tx.us/news_release.aspx?id=2147501866 I just wanted to provide the link from TEA which shows NO TPM WAS USED IN 2011. The decision to make a change was late in the testing season, but because of the controversy the commissioner of Ed decided to pull TPM. We already see the big decline in the number of schools that missed AYP using this years STAAR data. That would be a better list to watch. These schools are on this list because of TAKS data 2 years ago. It isn't even relevant. Just thought you would know...disdblogger if you are going to put it out be factul. We are counting on you!

13th Year
13th Year like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @disdblogger Ok, so TEA released this "bad school" information based only on data from 2010-2011???  TEA did not use ANY STAAR data???   Say it ain't so....

Bookish ish
Bookish ish

@Slow news Wait! Could it be that the DMN is "releasing" this bit of old news just so the cabinet (including new hires) could use this very low threshold as the basis to get their performance pay. It makes sense, if next year we only get 30 schools in the nasty list, this may qualify as an improvement and the cabinet will cash in.

Exceeds and Proud
Exceeds and Proud

 @Michael_MacNaughton  @Slow news

 Unfortunately, Mr. MacNaughton, I am afraid that the State of Texas bit off more than it can chew by replacing the TAKS with the STAAR.

 

What I am worried about is the huge delay in getting results back, is the State Board trying to get out of presenting this information because the results - state wide - are abysmal? Did the developers over-shoot the mark and make the test too hard? You know - make it comparable to what kids in other states would be able to comprehend?

 

Governor Good Hair has to be able to go back and say that the $5 BILLION cuts in educational fuding had no effect on student performance.

Michael_MacNaughton
Michael_MacNaughton

 @Slow news

I agree it may be slow news...but that doesn't make it less important.  Two major problems will rear their ugly heads shortly...first is the cost, and DISD's inability to fund, remediation for those kids who need it.  Second will be the impact of the STAAR test on major urban districts.  We will see a tremendous increase of Academically Unacceptable schools at the elementary school level.  This, in turn, should raise the issue in the politically quiet Hispanic community who may finally notice that they are under-represented on the board and under-served by the district.  It should be an interesting next two years.

Slow news
Slow news like.author.displayName 1 Like

@13th Year @disdblogger Correct. STAAR results did not factor in this list. I wonder why this is even news. These schools were already in the list two years ago because schools retain their ratings for two years due to transition from TAKS to STAAR.

Persona non grata
Persona non grata like.author.displayName 1 Like

Put the parents of the 35 schools on a pay for performance plan. Only those families with a child who failed any one of the 2013 tests would qualify (of course, don't announce any information about implementing the plan until AFTER the 2013 tests are completed). Students transferring in for the 2014 year would NOT be eligible. Qualifying students must be present on the first day of school for the 2013-14 year and reward is forfeited upon transferring to any other school. Upon the release of the 2014 STAAR results, parents receive $3,000 for each child in the family that passes ALL the tests. Total award forfeited if even one child in the family fails even one test. At the beginning of next year, each participating family sees their total pending payout on each grade card. That balance may DECLINE through the year by predetermined amounts for demonstrations of lack of parental support: tardiness, missed conferences, office referrals, missed homework, every D/F, failure to attend at least half of the PTO/PTA, rude/obnoxious behavior with school personnel, etc. 1st suspension results in $1000 reduction that can be replaced with a hefty school community service stint AFTER school (custodial work?). 2nd suspension or expulsion results in forfeiture of the award for ALL students in the family. Sadly, I don't believe that the total payout would be very costly for the district...NOTE: I can find no references for a plan like this for parents.

Persona non grata
Persona non grata

And, how about a matching reward for the teachers of each qualifying child? PAY for effective parent/teacher TEAM instead of putting all the responsibility on the teachers?

This comment has been deleted

1 4 the road
1 4 the road like.author.displayName 1 Like

Notice the amount of "school choice charters" on the list missing AYP across the state. Link: http://ritter.tea.state.tx.us/ayp/2012/sip_cam.pdf

Sentinella
Sentinella like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

 @1 4 the road Yes. Also note the public school districts generally held in higher esteem, such as Plano or Richardson. They may only have a few schools on the list, but lo! and behold! they correspond directly with the poorer sections of town. What are the odds of such a phenomenon taking place, when all these crappy teachers are the source of the problem? 

Beer in Hand
Beer in Hand like.author.displayName 1 Like

Ahhh, frack. Who cares? They just hired two new guys with a combined total salary of $384,000--and one had to repay his last district when he made the mistake of making bad credit card purchases. Sound familiar, folks? They change places, but the same mentality exists up there on Ross Avenue. If you are not angry, you are not paying attention.

Exceeds and Proud
Exceeds and Proud like.author.displayName 1 Like

@Beer in Hand Are you shiitakiing me? I wanted to spend a weekend away from it all, been sick wanted to recuperate and ...what? Does Freakin' Magic Mike just not get it? Is this not just another case of ssdd? It kind of makes you want to just say "F it all!" are you stupid?

Bilingual_Teacher
Bilingual_Teacher like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

I like to use the analogy: “Teaching in DISD is like trying to dig a tunnel with a spoon.” The easiest and faster way to explain failure is blaming the teachers. Why? Because it is the only thing administrators can control. We all know the problem, but we don’t do anything about it. Year after year the real issues are ignored and shovel down the carpet.

 

Teachers are over worked, there are not enough books or incomplete sets, no consumables, less money for copies, no technology upgrades, students show up unprepared or unmotivated, parent phone numbers that are blocked or disconnected, very little or no support from administrators, and the list goes on and on.

Administrators don’t give teachers enough credit. Everyday they perform miracles with what they have and still get disrespected time and time again. Shameful situation… 

 

Ghost
Ghost

 @Bilingual_Teacher Why do teachers get blamed? Because EVERY time you tried to point the finger at parents and the communities that don't care for education-you get tons of excuses and get called a crybaby.

Look at this list only 3 high schools in the Southern sector are MIA. That all can not be on teachers and school staff. Look at what W T White is doing to support kids-they are on this list. So are we going to say it's the school? Those folks are trying.

Little Red Hen
Little Red Hen like.author.displayName 1 Like

DMN article states that " DISD officials said they hadn’t had a chance to analyze the list." Are we supposed to believe this was a surprise to them?

Persona non grata
Persona non grata like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

No worries! DISD has a plan that will make our achievement rates soar: bludgeon teachers to sussess! Nothing spells success like frightened, angry and hunkered down teachers!

Exceeds and Proud
Exceeds and Proud like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

@Persona non grata There's a card one of my buddies gave me, it says: "The beatings will continue until morale improves!" Apropos, no?

Sentinella
Sentinella like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @Exceeds and Proud  @Persona I've been seeing and hearing that phrase more and more frequently these days, though "No Child Left Standing" and "No Teacher Left Behind" are making strong comebacks. After all, testing season is upon us.

Thoughtful Reader
Thoughtful Reader like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

Unfortunately, I predict that the district will spin this news to say that these failures are all the fault of the teachers. They will use this as justification for all of the nonsense they are doing in their war against good teachers.   The measures they are taking will NOT get rid of the bad teachers; the good ones will get fed up and leave on their own accord.  The bad teachers are protected by someone (a principal, ED, trustee, someone else in power) and the new system being implemented will not change that, and so they will remain.  Nothing Miles is doing will fix this problem.

disdblogger
disdblogger moderator like.author.displayName 1 Like

With the implementation of STAAR next year I predict the number of AU schools will at least double.

Persona non grata
Persona non grata like.author.displayName 1 Like

You're forgetting the Miracle Workers (TFA) that will pull us out of the abyss and will only need one year to do it. Fear not!

LastStraw
LastStraw like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 6 Like

Although this is not surprising with the top down micro-mgmt we've endured for several years and  continues at warp speed, I refuse to let this report spoil my day. The sun is shining brighter for the King is back in the building! Hope springs!

Our Heartfelt Thoughts and Prayers
We are deeply sorrowful for the loss of the students and adults in the tornado that struck Moore, Oklahoma just south of Oklahoma City this afternoon, Monday, May 20. Our hearts go out to the families and our friends who have experienced this horrible tragedy. You remain in our thoughts and prayers. God bless you all.

We have been asked by a reader to share this website with the teachers in DISD.

The reader states, "We are raising money to pay for the funeral of baby Victoria, daughter of our beloved friend and teacher at Frank Guzick Elementary school that tragically died on May 17, 2013."

We are glad to lend a helping hand. We have not confirmed the validity of this fund raising site. Be generous but, as always, be cautious when giving money on-line.

Recent Comments
  • Loading...
WELCOME

CONTACT US
E-MAIL DISDblog

STATISTICS
Monday, May 20, 9:00 a.m.
Unique Visitors: 42,532
Visits: 224,305
Pageviews: 476,131
Avg. Duration: 00:04:03

COMMENTS
You may make comments with your privacy completely protected! Click HERE for Detailed Instructions with Pictures

NOTES
We have turned on the "profanity filter" for the blog because of one or two bad apples. We are seeing more and more profanity in the comments y, si, hablamos español. It means your comments will go into a pending folder and WILL NOT BE VISIBLE until one of us takes the time to login in and edit it. We know words are powerful and ideas even more so. Profanity isn't really necessary for emphasis or a substitute for passion here. Thank you.

Monday, May 20, 2013
Open Transfer Positions (539)
Teacher 2012-2013 School Year (111)
Teacher Assistant (133)

It has been interesting to see the number of teacher positions vary--from over 400 in the last weeks of October to around 300 in the first week of November as the press and blogs have put a spotlight on this issue. At the press briefing last week Mr. Miles was asked about teacher shortages and the large number of permanent substitutes by the new media and he tap-danced around the questions without any hard factual answers. The parents and students of the district deserve better.

Citizens wanting to speak at regular board meetings and briefings must sign up by calling Board Services at (972) 925-3720 no later than 5 p.m. on the day before the meeting.

Contact the Superintendent and Trustees:
3700 Ross Avenue, Box 1
Dallas, TX 75204

Superintendent Mike Miles
milesfm@dallasisd.org

Lew Blackburn, President
District 5
Term Expires 2013
lblackburn@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3718
Oak Lawn, West Dallas, Wilmer, Hutchins and portions of East Oak Cliff

Adam Medrano, 1st Vice President
District 8
Term Expires 2014
amedrano@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3721
Love Field, Northwest Dallas, and Central Dallas

Eric Cowan, 2nd Vice President
District 7
Term Expires 2013
ecowan@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3721
North Central Oak Cliff and parts of West Dallas

Nancy Bingham, Board Secretary
District 4
Term Expires 2013
nbingham@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3722
Southeast Dallas, Seagoville, Balch Springs

Elizabeth Jones
District 1
Term Expires 2015
elizabethjones@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3722
Northwest Dallas, including North Dallas, Addison, parts of Carrollton and Farmers Branch

Mike Morath
District 2
Term Expires 2014
mmorath@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3721
North and Near East Dallas

Dan Micciche
District 3
Term Expires 2015
danmicciche@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3722
Northeast Dallas

Carla Ranger
District 6
Term Expires 2014
cranger@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3722
Southwest Dallas

Bernadette Nutall
District 9
Term Expires 2015
benutall@dallasisd.org
(972) 925-3721
South Dallas and parts of Downtown Dallas, Pleasant Grove, Deep Ellum, Uptown, and East Dallas

"Republics are created by the virtue, public spirit and intelligence of the citizens. They fall when the wise are banished from the public councils because they dare to be honest and the profligate are rewarded because they flatter the people in order to betray them." --Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution, 1833

Archives